Does changing image contrast affect dynamic range or image quality?
Asked 4/2/2013
1 views
2 answers
0
If I increase or decrease contrast in editing, does that actually change the photo’s dynamic range, or just how tones are displayed? And does adding contrast make the image “better quality,” or can it reduce detail?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
5
Depends on what you are referring to.
Increasing the contrast using an image editor software means making the darks darker and the brights brighter, and decreasing means the other way around. Increasing the contrast will cause loss of details since you won't be able to distinguish one tone from another as well as you could before you made them darker or brighter, and decreasing might give you more details, depending on your camera's or film's dynamic range and some other factors (I'll explain it later). On the other hand, increasing the contrast might make your images more vivid, whereas decreasing it might make them more dull:

On the image above, the middle one is the original, the left one is with decreased contrast (notice how it is more dull) and the one in the right has increased contrast (more vivid). You can clearly see a loss in detail on the one in the right, with increased contrast, whereas there really isn't any gain in details in the one in the left. Why? For two reasons:
Dynamic Range
I used a cheap film to take that picture, it does not have a good dynamic range, i.e. there wasn't much of a difference between the darkest and the brightest tones to start with. The same is usually valid to cheap digital cameras.
The editing process (most important!)
I edited that picture with an image editing software, after it was already processed and developed, which is the equivalent of editing a JPEG instead of a RAW if you shoot digital. What you are doing is editing what was somehow already edited by the lab guy or by the camera's software, it's like trying to change the colors of a painting that was already painted.
On the other hand, if your camera / film has a good dynamic range and you do your magic while developing the film or if you edit RAW, you can gain a lot of details by decreasing the contrast and messing around with some other lightning settings - the dynamic range is set by your camera/film, but you can mess around with it, paying the price for it, which is loss/gain in details for gain/loss in vivid tones. I can't develop the picture again, but I edited only certain areas of it to simulate it:

You can clearly see in the sky and buildings (brighter tones) that I gained a lot of details by decreasing the contrast and messing with some other lightning settings.
Originally by user17831. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user17831
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Changing contrast in editing mainly remaps tones: darker tones get darker and brighter tones get brighter, or vice versa. It does not increase the scene or sensor dynamic range your camera originally captured.
In the edited image itself, contrast can change how much of the available tonal range is being used, but only within the limits of the file’s bit depth and the captured data. Pushing contrast too far can clip shadows/highlights and merge nearby tones, which means lost detail. Lowering contrast can sometimes reveal more visible detail, but may also make the image look flatter or duller.
So, does it improve quality? Not inherently. Contrast is mostly an aesthetic adjustment. More contrast can make an image look punchier or more vivid; less contrast can look softer or moodier. Either can be “better” depending on the subject and intent.
If the original image is too flat, underexposed, overexposed, or simply needs tonal shaping, adjusting contrast can improve the result. But it doesn’t create new dynamic range, and excessive contrast usually reduces usable detail rather than improving technical quality.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why can electronic shutter mode reduce dynamic range compared with a mechanical shutter?
Why does a high-contrast scene cause lost detail in a photo?
Should you intentionally underexpose digital photos to protect highlights?
Why does an image seem less sharp when I increase its DPI?
What is DRI, and how is it different from HDR?