Does a tripod’s apex material matter for vibration damping: magnesium vs aluminum?
Asked 9/6/2016
5 views
2 answers
0
For a carbon-fiber tripod, the apex/spider and leg joints may be made from either magnesium or aluminum alloy. If two otherwise similar tripods differed only in those parts, would one material reduce vibration better? I’m specifically asking about damping of camera-induced vibration, not weight or corrosion.
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
9y ago
2 Answers
9
TL;DR: You can't really optimize the tripod apex for vibration reduction, just the legs.
Note: I've also heard the apex referred to as a spider. It's the (usually) single piece where the legs come together — the center structure.
I think you're worrying about optimizing the wrong part (i.e., the apex) for vibration. They are either cast, or milled from from a billet piece of metal. The geometry of the apex is compact and stiff. Its whole point is to be strong, in order to hold up to the stresses the legs impart on it.
A material's ability to transmit and/or dampen vibration is from deformation — the material literally elongates, bends, "squeezes", etc., tiny amounts. Absorbing vibrations is just converting kinetic energy (i.e., motion) into heat energy (albeit an imperceptible amount).
The legs of a tripod are designed to be as light as possible while spanning a long distance (relative to the cross-sectional diameter and thickness of the tubing wall). It just so happens that the choice of material in the legs also can have vibration damping characteristics, but that really just overcomes the fact that the issue of vibration was created by the long/thin geometry of the leg to begin with!
The vibrations you're hoping to reduce are actually created by the legs. As long & thin structures, they are basically oscillators "pinned" or fixed at both ends, with a certain characteristic frequency (probably below about 20 Hz). External forces, such as wind passing over the legs induce them to oscillate at their natural frequency. This oscillation is identical in nature to large structures, such as the infamous Tacoma Narrows Bridge (that literally oscillated to the point of self-destruction). Think about an oscillating suspension bridge for a moment: what can you possibly do at the nodes (i.e., the ends of the bridge) to stop the middle from oscillating? You can't. You have to address the problem along the length and/or in the middle, where the generated forces are the largest (and by reflection, where you have the most ability to impart counterforces).
Thus, it is the very material of the tripod's legs that diminishes the vibration they produce. The apex has no ability to absorb the vibrations, because it is one of the endpoints, the upper node, of each leg.
Originally by user11924. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11924
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
In practice, apex material is unlikely to be the deciding factor in tripod vibration. The tripod spider/apex is a compact, stiff part whose job is strength; vibration damping mainly comes from parts that flex, especially the legs. Since damping requires tiny deformation that converts motion into heat, the legs and overall design usually matter far more than whether the apex is magnesium or aluminum.
From the answers provided: magnesium alloys are often described as having similar specific stiffness to aluminum alloys, but potentially higher damping capacity. However, one answer also notes that much of the damping in real structures comes from joints, interfaces, and overall construction rather than the bulk metal alone.
So if you could isolate only the apex material, magnesium might have a theoretical damping advantage, but it is likely small in a real tripod compared with leg design, joint quality, stiffness, and resonance behavior of the whole system. If vibration control is the goal, focus more on the legs, locks, head, and testing the complete tripod/camera setup than on apex material alone.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI9y ago