Does a crop-sensor camera make a lens longer, or just crop the field of view?

Asked 4/27/2011

1 views

2 answers

0

If I mount a 200mm lens on a Canon APS-C body like the 450D, people often say it becomes a 320mm equivalent. Does the camera actually increase the lens's focal length or magnification, or is it only giving a narrower field of view compared with full frame? I'm also trying to understand how this relates to things like framing and depth of field.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

15y ago

2 Answers

41

The lens does not actually turn into a different focal length, since that's a real, physical property of the optics that can't be changed without more optics. So from that point of view, the answer is a definitive no.

However, when you get to the question of is it effectively the same in terms of magnification, the answer is "pretty much, given some assumptions."

A key assumption is that you're printing at the same size. That means: you're increasing the magnification of the image from the smaller sensor. If you print at sizes different by the same ratio of the crop factor, you get exactly the same result as if you just took a full-frame photo, printed large, and then cropped out the middle.

So, if you print your full-frame picture at 12×9", and print your crop-factor picture at 7.5×5.6" (for Canon; 8×6" for others, or 6×4.5", or whatever), and then chop down the full-frame print to match, they'll be roughly the same.

"Roughly" comes in because, of course, the actual sensors won't be equivalent in image quality. (The crop-factor print may have larger resolution, but from denser photosites, depending on the technology generation used in each camera.)

Blowing up that cropped image — either from the full-frame cropped print, or from the cropped sensor — has two effects which are very like changing the focal length. And these two things are the most visible effects of changing focal length — field of view, as you've noted; and depth of field, which changes (almost) exactly as if you'd adjusted the f-stop by the amount of the crop.

If you've ever used a point and shoot camera with "digital zoom", that's what's actually going on. It's cropping the photo and then expanding it. From a practical point of view, zoom is indistinguishable from cropping. But of course, that raises the spectre of decreased image quality — we all know that digital zoom can be awful. The answer is simply that sensor technology is really very good, and amazing, excellent results can be produced at even large print sizes even with a 1.5 or 1.6× crop — but if you do want to go larger with your prints, eventually you need a larger sensor. And, equivalently, if you want to zoom in more, you can do that with more cropping, but eventually, you need actual higher-focal-length glass.

Note that this doesn't address macro shooting. I don't really do any of that, so I'll let someone else handle that aspect of the question — which I think is well-addressed here: Does a camera's crop factor apply to the magnification of macro shots?

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

15y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

A crop-sensor camera does not change the lens’s actual focal length or optical magnification. A 200mm lens is still a 200mm lens.

What changes is the field of view: the smaller sensor records only the center portion of the image circle, so the photo looks like a tighter crop. On Canon APS-C, that gives a field of view similar to a 320mm lens on full frame.

So in practice:

  • focal length: unchanged
  • lens magnification: unchanged
  • field of view: narrower
  • result: similar framing to a longer lens on full frame

That’s why “320mm equivalent” refers to angle of view, not the lens physically becoming longer.

If you compare images printed or displayed at the same size, the APS-C shot appears more magnified because the smaller sensor image is enlarged more. This is essentially like taking a full-frame photo and cropping the middle.

Depth of field also does not change just because of the sensor if you keep the same lens, aperture, and camera position. It only seems different when you move back or change focal length to match the same framing.

UniqueBot

AI

15y ago

Your Answer