Do extension tubes on an APS-C camera change the crop factor of a full-frame lens?

Asked 8/22/2016

5 views

2 answers

0

I’m using a Canon 40mm f/2.8 lens made for full frame on a Canon T5 (APS-C). Since the sensor is smaller than the lens’s image circle, only part of that image is recorded. If I add extension tubes between the lens and camera, will that make more of the lens’s image reach the APS-C sensor and reduce the apparent crop, or will it do the opposite?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

1

The standard camera lens/body combination stops the forward movement of the lens when 0.1 magnification is obtained. At this close up positon, a 10 cm height is imaged 1 cm on film/sensor. The f/numbers engraved on the lens barrel are only valid when the typical lens is imaging objects at infinity. As we move closer and closer by elongating the lens to film/sensor, the magnification obtained increases. Magnification means that the image forming light rays are being spread thinner. That translates to less light energy in any given unit area.

We can easily calculate the magnitude of the loss in image brightness due to magnification. We are talking about the Bellows Factor formula.
BF = (M +1) ^2 That’s magnification plus 1 squared. For the 0.1 magnification positon BF = (0.1+1) ^2 = 1.21 about 1/3 of an f/stop (we must compensate by aperture or shutter speed).

We handle the BF just like a filter factor, it is a multiplier. Suppose the exposure for this subject is is f/16 @ 1 second as determined by a hand-held light meter. We apply the BF = 1 X 1.21 = 1.21 seconds. In other words, at the 0.1 magnification position we are required to increase the exposure from 1 second to 1.21 seconds to compensate for light loss as the image forming rays transvers the lens. If we increase the lens to sensor distance an obtain magnification 0.5 the BF = 2.25. In other words, if we obtain magnification ½ life size we compensated by increasing the exposure from 1 second to 2.25 seconds. If we obtain life size, magnification 1, the BF is( 1 + 1) ^2 = 4. Now the exposure time must be increased from 1 second to 4 seconds. That’s two f/stops. If we obtain magnification 2 (twice life-size) the BF is (2 +1)^2 = 9. We increase the shutter speed from 1 second to 9 seconds.

All this is independent of the lens unless it is a macro. A macro is optimized to image at magnification 1 (unity). The design of the lens compensates for BF thus the f/numbers stay true.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Extension tubes do not reduce crop factor. They move the lens farther from the sensor, which is used to focus closer and increase magnification.

As the lens is extended, the projected image spreads over a larger area. Your APS-C sensor stays the same size, so it captures an even smaller portion of that image circle, not more of it. In practice, this means:

  • no change to the camera’s crop factor
  • narrower field of view at close focus
  • higher magnification
  • less light per unit area reaching the sensor

So extension tubes make the image dimmer and more magnified; they do not help the APS-C sensor “see more” of what a full-frame lens projects.

If you wanted more of the image circle to fit on the sensor, you’d need the lens effectively closer to the sensor or use a focal reducer designed for that purpose—not extension tubes.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer