Do dual-camera phones beat a single higher-megapixel phone for indoor video?

Asked 9/27/2017

2 views

2 answers

0

I'm choosing an Android phone mainly for indoor video recording, such as lectures to upload to YouTube. My current phone records acceptable video but overheats and lags, so I want a replacement.

I'm comparing phones with:

  • a single camera around 24 MP, or
  • dual cameras such as 12 MP + 12 MP or 16 MP + 8 MP.

As a beginner, I'm confused about how much megapixel count and dual-camera design actually matter for video quality. For indoor recording, is a dual-camera phone generally better than a single higher-megapixel camera, or are other factors more important?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

2

MP is all but one parameter that would influence photo quality. It determines the maximum number of pixels in the image that the camera would take. It doesn't determine how good the sensor is, whether it's better taking low light, etc etc...

Whether the lense is good optically will contribute to photo quality. On a smartphone, the software package that processes the sensor output is also very important to the perceived quality of the photo.

There are also some phones with optical image stabilization now, which would help with counteracting against shaking.

With that out of the way, there are also different ways smartphone manufacturers made use of dual camera. In the past, there was a bit of a fad to have 2 of the same camera to take 3D pictures. That didn't take off.

iPhone 7+ went a different route, with a single wide angle, and a 2x telephoto, so it's possible to take some zoomed in shots without resorting to software zoom. That and using AI techniques to take portraits to mimic wide aperature DSLR shots.

So to determine what is "better", what kind of photography you want to take? If you like night shots, and don't care about portraits with the fake blur background, then you probably don't care about dual cameras.

So figure out what you want, and look at actual reviews comparing the photos instead of deducing quality from a number.

Edit: To respond to your intended use, having two cameras most likely won't make any difference compared to a single camera, unless the phone you pick has a telephoto vs wide angle camera, and you'd want the optical zoom capability.

Heat on a camera phone, when it's doing a lot of processing is unavoidable. A large phone with metal back may help with dissipate the heat, but recording long videos are not good for battery life.

Another alternative might be to find a used DSLR / mirrorless in good shape, and use that to record videos. It would give you a lot more options for your video production, at the expense of overall cost of owning a piece of hardware that only does video.

Originally by user67603. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user67603

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Megapixel count alone does not tell you which phone will record better video. More MP mainly means more image pixels; it does not guarantee better low-light performance, better color, less noise, or smoother video.

For indoor video, other factors usually matter more:

  • sensor quality
  • lens quality
  • image processing/software
  • optical image stabilization (if available)
  • how well the phone handles heat and sustained recording

A dual-camera phone is not automatically better. Phone makers use dual cameras for different purposes, such as zoom, depth effects, or sometimes improving low-light performance. So a 12 MP + 12 MP setup may help in some designs, but it is not inherently superior to a single 24 MP camera.

Also, very high pixel counts can be less helpful in low light if the system is not well designed, and camera shake can still blur results.

So for recording lectures indoors, prioritize overall video performance and stabilization over megapixel numbers or simply having two cameras.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer