Do dichroic filter changes affect exposure time in color darkroom printing?

Asked 11/14/2018

3 views

2 answers

0

When making color prints with a Beseler 23C III XL dichroic enlarger, should exposure time be changed when adjusting the cyan, yellow, and magenta filtration? I’ve seen conflicting advice: some sources say dichroic heads should not need exposure compensation, others say yellow has little effect but magenta and cyan require changes, and some recommend adjusting exposure whenever filtration changes. What is the practical guidance?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

1

As you dial in higher and higher values for any of three dichroic glass filters, it will be necessary to apply a correction (filter factor that increases exposure). I can provide approximate values but there are many valuables therefor you will need to run your own tests. Enlarging exposure meters are available however you can use most any exposure meter, placed on the baseboard; it will show light level reductions as you dial in more filtration. Dial in .10 = 1/3 stop Dial in .30 = 2/3 stop Dial in .50Y = 1 stop

Why dichroic? All filters fade in time however enlargers are particularly bad because of the bright light and high heat. We started color printing with dyed-in-the-mass gelatin (CC filters Color Correcting) and acetate (CP filters Color Printing). Because these fade quickly in the lamphouse, we turned to dichroic glass. A dichroic filter is made by depositing micro thin coats of metals or oxides on heat resistant glass. These work by the interference principles like the rainbow you see on soap bubbles. Anyway, the metal or oxide coats are inert. Dichroic filters reflect away heat and the colors of light they do not pass thus they run much colder than their dyed-in-the-mass cousin. Thus a yellow dichroic looks blue by reflected light and yellow by transmitted light etc. (Greek for twice). A magenta dichroic looks magenta by transmitted light and green by reflected light. A cyan dichroic looks cyan by transmitted light red by reflected light.

When we print color negative film, with the enlarger lens wide-open, the paper is hit with an abundance of all three light primary colors (red – green – blue). We stop down the enlarger lens to reduce these light level. As you continue to stop down, the red light energy becomes correct first. This is because of the ISO assignments (actually paper speeds). With the red exposing energy correct, we address the green and blue light energy, both remain in excess.

Now we impose a green blocking filter. This is the magenta filter. We dial the magenta value until the green light energy is correct. Next we dial in a blue blocking filter. This is the yellow filter. In this way we adjust the exposure of the paper/negative combination to cause the paper to receive correct red – green – blue exposures. Again -- Red achieved by stopping down the lens, Green achieved by adjusting magenta filter and blue achieved by adjusting yellow filter.

This scheme avoids the use of the cyan filter. We avoid because the cyan filter is difficult to make and all cyan filters pass unwanted frequencies. The yellow filter is almost a perfect blue blocker. The magenta is an OK green but far from perfect. The cyan filter is so bad, it has a high filter factor due to the fact that we must dial in more and more to do the job. This induces cross-talk. Better to use the iris diaphragm to control the red energy level. Thus the paper layer speeds are set so this scheme can be used.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—changing dichroic filtration can reduce the light reaching the paper, so exposure may need to be increased as filtration increases. In practice, higher values of any of the dichroic filters act like a filter factor and can require compensation.

A practical way to handle it is to test your own enlarger rather than rely on a fixed rule. Light source, head design, and filtration range can all affect the result. An enlarging meter is helpful, but even a regular exposure meter on the baseboard can show how light output changes as you dial in more filtration.

From the community answer, approximate corrections were:

  • 0.10 filtration change: about 1/3 stop
  • 0.30 filtration change: about 2/3 stop
  • 0.50Y: about 1 stop

So the safest guidance is: don’t assume filtration changes are exposure-neutral. Measure or make test strips whenever you make meaningful color-filter adjustments, especially larger ones. That’s more reliable than following a universal formula.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer