Do an 18-55mm and 55-200mm together cover the same range as an 18-200mm lens?
Asked 4/13/2014
5 views
2 answers
0
I’m new to interchangeable-lens cameras and have a Sony a6000 with an 18-55mm kit lens. I’m comparing adding a 55-200mm lens versus replacing it with a single 18-200mm superzoom.
If I use the 18-55mm and 55-200mm together, do they give me essentially the same field-of-view coverage as an 18-200mm lens, just split across two lenses? Aside from needing to swap lenses, is there anything else I should consider?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
9
In terms of which angles of view the lens(es) will allow you to select, you're correct: the combination of an 18-55 lens and a 55-200 lens will let you choose from exactly the same angles of view as a single 18-200 lens.
However, I think you are missing a couple of important points, both of which are well covered in this answer: you'll get better image quality and a better maximum aperture with the 18-55 / 55-200 combination than you will with the 18-200. On the other hand, you'll be carrying around two lenses and having to change them - at which point, it's a personal decision as to which matters more for you.
The other minor point I'd pull up is that "zoom ratio" isn't really a useful concept for interchangeable lenses; as I think you've realised, it's a concept which makes sense only for lenses which start at similar focal lengths. As such, it's vaguely useful for most compact cameras, which tend to start somewhere in the 20-28mm (equivalent) range, but pretty much worthless for comparing most interchangeable lenses. See this question for more details if you want to.
Originally by user11371. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user11371
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. In terms of focal-length coverage and selectable angles of view, an 18-55mm plus a 55-200mm gives you essentially the same overall range as an 18-200mm: from 18mm wide to 200mm telephoto, with the handoff at 55mm.
The main difference is convenience. A single 18-200mm avoids lens changes, while the two-lens setup means swapping lenses when you want to move between ranges.
The tradeoff is that the two-lens combination will generally give you better image quality and a better maximum aperture than a single 18-200mm superzoom.
Also, “zoom ratio” is not very useful for comparing interchangeable-lens setups. What matters more is the actual focal-length range and the image quality/aperture tradeoffs.
So your understanding is basically correct: same practical framing range, but with different convenience and optical-performance tradeoffs.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
What are the trade-offs of replacing an 18-55mm and 55-200mm with an 18-200mm superzoom?
Why are 18-200mm superzoom lenses more expensive than buying 18-55mm and 55-200mm separately?
Will an 18-55mm lens at 55mm look the same as a 55-200mm lens at 55mm?
How does the Sony 55-210mm compare to the 18-55mm kit lens?
Should I keep my Nikon 18-55mm if I buy the 16-85mm for a D5100?