Can you test a Canonet QL17 shutter without film, and how should you check it?

Asked 9/10/2019

4 views

2 answers

0

I’m getting into film photography and want to see whether my dad’s old Canonet QL17 still works, especially since these cameras can have sticky shutter blades. Is it safe to fire the shutter with no film loaded? What’s a practical way to check whether the shutter is functioning properly, and whether the speeds seem reasonable?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

2

Yes, you can fire the camera without film.

In general, your test with a film rangefinder/SLR would be to open the back, remove the lens, and cycle and test every selectable shutter speed.

You’re not going to be able to confirm if your 1/30 selection is actually 1/40 or 1/20. You may be able to run a timer for longer shutter speeds to test for accuracy...but even if they are accurate, there’s no guarantee that the shorter speeds are too.

Instead, look for proper function (as you noted, no stickiness).

Then, get a roll of film and test the camera. Figure out a perfect exposure of a subject using a meter or another camera and then roll through every shutter speed that you can on that subject. Keep notes of your frame and chosen speed. Then, check the negs.

You should have the same exposure all the way through. Look for anomalies. Pending the type of anomaly, you can figure out the problem.

If you really, really want to set up the camera to run properly, then get it serviced. You’re looking at ~$250 in the States, assuming just a CLA (more of replacement parts are needed).

For the Canonet Specifically, please see https://camerapedia.fandom.com/wiki/Canon_Canonet_QL_17_GIII

The shutter speeds can be manually set and should be for any testing. Do note the battery advice in the article:

It was designed to use the PX625 mercury battery, no longer available in the US. The circuitry in the camera holds up well against slightly higher voltages, so you can use a PX625A alkaline battery as a drop-in replacement, but you will find your exposures tend to be slightly off. Only the autoexposure system requires a battery, however. The mechanical shutter functions perfectly under manual settings with no battery whatsoever.

Originally by user67377. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user67377

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes — you can fire the Canonet QL17 without film.

A good basic check is to open the camera back and fire the shutter through all selectable speeds while watching for consistent operation and any obvious sticking. That will tell you whether the shutter is functioning, but not whether each speed is perfectly accurate.

For slower speeds, you may be able to roughly judge timing by ear or with a timer. For faster speeds, accuracy is much harder to confirm just by watching.

The best practical test is to run a roll of film through the camera. Meter a scene with stable, unchanging light, make exposures at different shutter speeds, and keep notes of which frame used which setting. Then compare the negatives: exposures that should match or change predictably will reveal whether the shutter is behaving sensibly.

So: dry-firing is fine for a function check, but a film test is the reliable way to evaluate real shutter performance.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer