Can you color-correct from a known non-neutral color sample instead of a gray card?
Asked 5/24/2015
3 views
2 answers
0
If I don’t have a neutral gray reference in a photo, can I use a known object color instead, such as a piece of clothing that was photographed accurately at another time, to correct color in Lightroom or Photoshop?
I understand how to use a gray card and the white balance eyedropper. My question is specifically about cases where there is no neutral reference, and sometimes the lighting is poor or mixed so simple temperature/tint adjustment is not enough.
How are color targets or color plaques used in this situation? Is there a practical method or tool for matching a known non-gray sample, or is it mostly manual trial and error?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
11y ago
2 Answers
3
You can do this manually if you know what the color is supposed to be. It is similar to the process of calibrating to a neutral sample. The results will not be as accurate as if you use a grayscale, especially with mixed color lighting.
You should work from a RAW file if available.
- First, set a best guess white balance.
- Measure the known color in your image in terms of R,G, and B (Red, Green, Blue) values
- Compare the measurement to your target
- Adjust the white balance accordingly
- Repeat from step 2 until the color is matched
Example: if the sample is 55,87,123 and it is supposed to be 55,82,125 you will leave the red alone, take out some green, and add a little blue.
Hint (added after your followup) to make RGB edits with temp/tint:
- To add red: Add yellow and magenta.
- To remove red, remove yellow and magenta.
- To change blue, use temp.
- To change green use tint.
Caution: when sampling the color, especially a fabric use a large sample (example 20x20 pixels) instead of a point sample to get an average reading.
Be aware that there are color shifts that can occur at certain hues and values, for various reasons, that will affect some parts of the image but not others.
Another tip: If you want to save money, get some paint sample cards from a home improvement store, including neutrals, and paste them to a piece of foam board. This would be better than calibrating to a shirt.
Originally by user40058. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user40058
11y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, but it is less reliable than using a true neutral target. A gray card works best because white balance is fundamentally about neutralizing color casts; using a colored sample can help, but accuracy drops quickly with mixed lighting, changing angles, shadows, or different camera/rendering responses.
A practical approach is:
- Work from RAW if possible.
- Set a reasonable initial white balance.
- Measure the sample’s RGB values in the image.
- Compare them to the known target values.
- Adjust WB and/or individual color channels, then re-measure and repeat.
This is often partly manual and trial-and-error. With difficult indoor or mixed light, temperature/tint alone may not be enough, and channel curves/levels may be needed.
Color targets are typically used as a known reference to compare captured colors against expected values, then build or apply corrections from that comparison.
For Photoshop, one community-suggested tool is iCorrect EditLab Pro, which supports “memory color” matching. Still, even with tools, a non-neutral reference is generally a compromise versus a proper gray card or color checker shot under the same lighting.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI11y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do I set white balance when there’s no neutral gray or white in the photo?
How do I find a neutral reference to set white balance in a photo?
How should I use gray and white cards in GIMP to set white balance for artwork reproduction?
Why do different gray targets give different white balance readings?
How can I verify whether a gray card is truly color neutral?