Can the same image sensor deliver different dynamic range or color depth in different camera bodies?

Asked 5/28/2016

6 views

2 answers

0

If two cameras use the same underlying sensor, can they still produce different measured results for things like dynamic range or color depth? For example, the Nikon D7000 and Sony A55 are often said to share the same sensor, yet lab tests report different performance. Ignoring brand arguments and focusing on the technical side: can the same sensor produce different results in different bodies, and if so, why?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

6

DxO are not specifically inaccurate, but like any lab testing the methodology is important to the interpretation of results.

The result as seen in files (used to obtain measurements) is a result of the WHOLE image processing chain, not merely one aspect. Every part of the image pathway is important to contributing to the accuracy of the capture process.

For example the lens affects those characteristics of light to a huge degree before you even get to the sensor which can be driven using different sensitivity settings, it outputs to various Op Amps (to raise/lower ISO) and an A/D converter which digitise what is (at that point) an Analogue signal.

All that is before you've even hit the Digital side of the image pathway, which while output is branded as raw, there is always some level of manipulation or encoding or interpretation when it is processed to see what the figures are.

Stop worrying about it, get the camera that does the things you want it to do, that you can afford and that you feel comfortable with.

TL;DR: Not only is it possible, it's LIKELY that two different make/models of camera have different characteristics.

Originally by user14028. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user14028

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. A sensor is only one part of the imaging chain, so two cameras using the same basic sensor can still measure and perform differently.

Dynamic range and color depth are affected by more than the silicon itself, including:

  • analog gain / ISO circuitry
  • amplifiers and readout electronics
  • the A/D converter
  • filtering above the sensor, such as the Bayer/color filter
  • firmware and any processing applied even to “raw” output
  • operating conditions such as sensor temperature, which can change noise levels

Those differences can change noise, signal quality, and how much usable shadow/highlight information is retained, which in turn affects lab measurements.

Also, “same sensor” may only mean the same base sensor design, not that every supporting component around it is identical.

So the short answer is: yes, the same sensor can technically produce different dynamic range, color depth, and noise results in different camera bodies because the final image data depends on the entire capture and readout pipeline, not just the sensor alone.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer