Can the image sensor itself cause vignetting on digital cameras?
Asked 10/15/2013
3 views
2 answers
0
Vignetting is usually blamed on the lens or on accessories like hoods and filters. But can a digital image sensor also cause vignetting or a similar edge darkening effect? Since light reaches the sensor at increasingly oblique angles toward the edges, especially on cameras with short flange distances and large sensors, does the sensor structure contribute to light loss? How do modern cameras and lenses reduce this kind of sensor-related vignetting?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
10
Sensor based vignetting is a real problem for cameras with a large sensor and short flange distance (distance from mount to sensor). This is simply due to the oblique angles of incidence of light hitting the edges of the sensor, which isn't really flat like a piece of film, but contains a stack of objects starting with UV/IR/AA filters, followed by microlenses, colour filters, then many layers of silicon with the photosensitive area at the bottom of a deep well!
Near telecentric lens designs with large exit pupils largely solve the problem, but at the expense of making the lenses larger and more expensive.
Several things can be done to address the problem. Minimising the thickness of the filter stack certainly helps, though Leica attempted this with the M8 but made the IR filter too thin making the camera very sensitive to IR light, causing strange colours in the image (they even had to give out free IR screw on filters to angry customers).
Doing away with the anti-aliasing filter is another option that Leica and Sony (with the A7r) have pursued. Another option is offset microlenses (Leica M9) or elliptical microlenses (Leica M240), both of which attempt to aim the oblique light rays more effectively toward the photosites. The problem with this is that it compromises performance with longer focal length lenses.
The best solution is to get the photosensitive area of the silicon as close to the top as possible. One way is to thin the back of the wafer until it becomes transparent and then flip the sensor around so the readout circuitry is behind the photosite. These so called "back side illuminated" sensors are in existence, but only very recently in anything but very small cell phone cameras.
Finally organic sensors have been touted as the solution to ray angle issues, these have an organic layer that is photosensitive at the very top with circuity underneath. They are a way of production, but promise to eventually deliver the utopia of tiny wide angle lenses that ought to have been the result of doing away with the DSLR mirror!
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes. Digital cameras can show sensor-related edge darkening, often called pixel vignetting, in addition to ordinary lens vignetting.
A sensor is not just a flat light-sensitive surface. Light must pass through a filter stack, microlenses, color filters, and into photosites that sit at the bottom of tiny wells. Toward the edges of the frame, rays often hit at steeper angles, so some light is blocked or less efficiently collected, reducing signal near the corners.
This is most challenging with large sensors and short flange distances, because wide-angle rays can arrive more obliquely. Lens design matters a lot: near-telecentric designs with larger exit pupils send light toward the sensor more straight-on, which reduces the problem, though such lenses can be larger and more expensive.
Camera makers also help by keeping the sensor filter stack thinner and by using microlenses to direct incoming light into the photosites more effectively. So yes, the sensor can contribute to vignetting-like darkening, and modern camera/lens design works to minimize it.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How much light and effective resolution do Bayer color filter arrays reduce in digital cameras?
How does a short flange distance affect image quality and lens design?
Do digital cameras really show more chromatic aberration than film, and why?
Why are modern full-frame mirrorless 35mm f/1.4 lenses so much larger than Leica M 35mm f/1.4 lenses?
What limits how large digital camera sensors can be?