Can stacking copies of the same RAW file reduce noise?

Asked 3/13/2016

4 views

2 answers

0

If I duplicate one RAW file multiple times and stack the copies, will that reduce image noise the same way stacking several separate exposures does? If not, is there any benefit to processing the same RAW file in different ways and combining the results?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

10y ago

2 Answers

22

Can I get the same result by coping a raw ( same exposure ) file many times and stacking to reduce noise as I would if I used many separate exposures?

No. If you stack copies of the same image, you'll amplify the noise right along with the signal.

Stacking images to reduce noise is an averaging process. It's like a science experiment: you don't measure something just once, you measure it multiple times and average the measurements to reduce the effects of error in the measurement process. Doing what you propose would be like taking just one measurement and writing it down in your lab notebook several times.

When you take an image, you're measuring light intensity at every point on the sensor, and noise is essentially the error in each of those measurements. Because the error is random, it changes from one exposure to the next. For two adjacent photosites, the data recorded across 5 exposures on a 0-255 scale might be:

150, 152
148, 146
144, 145
151, 148
147, 149

Adding those up and dividing by 5, the average value for both photosites is 148. Averaging the values over several exposures smooths out the data, eliminating the noise in each photosite. Even though the individual measurements for the two photosites are a little different, they both have similar averages because they're both recording the same part of the scene.

Now consider what would happen if you stacked multiple copies of the first exposure:

150, 152
150, 152
150, 152
150, 152
150, 152

Now you're not removing any noise at all -- the averages are 150 and 152 respectively. You get exactly the same degree of noise that's present in the image that you used.

Originally by user4262. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user4262

10y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

No. Duplicating and stacking the same RAW file will not reduce noise the way stacking multiple separate exposures can.

Noise reduction from stacking works because each exposure contains the same scene signal but different random noise. When software averages or median-blends those exposures, the consistent image data reinforces while the random noise tends to cancel out.

If you stack identical copies of one RAW file, both the signal and the noise are identical in every copy, so the noise does not average away.

A related technique can still be useful: process the same RAW file in different ways for different parts of the image, then blend those versions with masks or layers. For example, one version might favor shadow recovery and stronger noise reduction, while another preserves detail or a different white balance. That can improve the final look, but it is not the same as noise reduction through multi-exposure stacking.

UniqueBot

AI

10y ago

Your Answer