Can I use a third-party tool to browse, cull, and edit metadata for a Lightroom catalog?
Asked 2/17/2016
4 views
2 answers
0
Lightroom feels sluggish for browsing and tagging, even with a relatively small catalog. I’d like to keep using Lightroom for non-destructive editing, but use another tool for faster ingesting, culling, viewing, and metadata work.
Is there a supported way to use a third-party application with Lightroom’s catalog, or is the better workflow to do metadata and culling before import?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
10y ago
2 Answers
3
The Lightroom catalog is a SQLite database, and it is possible to write programs that can access it that can cooperate with Lightroom. That said, most developers that I have seen choose to do this in a supported way through the plugin route and the API Adobe provides. There are plugins which can modify metadata, for example:
I suspect however that is not quite what you want; I suspect you want something for manual individual image updates, fast.
The best I have seen is a pre-import tool. I use Photo Mechanic from Camerabits, which is probably the best known ingestion/browsing/metadata tool going. It works best to ingest, cull, crop, and describe photos, then you can drag and drop them directly into Lightroom which invokes the Import and carries over all the metadata added.
Photo Mechanic is all about speed, it is widely used by photo journalists on deadline, to get images in fast and tag fully, then push out to whoever needs it. I found it cuts my sports shoot post processing by at least 30% and maybe 50%, because I then use Lightroom only for what Lightroom does well - final develop, and publishing.
In theory you can use it after the fact and exchange metadata through the XMP files both use, e.g. import to lightroom, write metadata to XMP, then browse with Photo Mechanic which updates XMP if you change metadata, then read the metadata in Lightroom. But I would expect this could lead to getting confused easily, and overwriting changes from one in the other. I think it is better to use it up front where the leverage is (culling), then use Lightroom from then on. After all metadata in Lightroom is fast to update in the Library module.
I am not aware of any programs that can actually edit the image that is cross compatible with lightroom (i.e. go back and forth between non-destructive editing in lightroom and in program X); I suppose one could be reverse engineered but I have never seen any attempts at that.
Originally by user28109. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user28109
10y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Lightroom’s catalog is a SQLite database, so in theory third-party software can access it, but directly editing the catalog is generally not the supported approach. Most developers use Lightroom’s plugin/API route instead.
If your goal is faster manual browsing, culling, and metadata entry, the common solution is not to edit the Lightroom catalog directly, but to use a pre-import tool. A well-known example is Photo Mechanic, which is widely used for ingesting, browsing, culling, cropping, and adding metadata before bringing files into Lightroom. That lets you keep Lightroom for raw processing and non-destructive edits while avoiding some of its slowness during selection and tagging.
So: yes, supported third-party integration exists mainly through plugins, but for a faster workflow the better answer is usually a separate ingest/metadata tool used before import rather than a standalone Lightroom catalog editor.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI10y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Will moving Lightroom photos or catalog files to an SSD improve performance?
How can I add external GPS metadata to Lightroom photos without losing edits?
Why is Lightroom Classic running very slowly on a fast new computer?
Can Lightroom 6 gallery publishing use Lightroom keywords for viewer navigation?
How can I manage archive drives and a keeper-only Lightroom catalog?