Can HDR software create a true HDR image from a single RAW file automatically?
Asked 8/31/2013
6 views
2 answers
0
A RAW file usually contains more tonal information than a JPEG, and many HDR workflows let you recover highlights and shadows from that RAW. So why do some people still bracket multiple exposures for HDR? If camera dynamic range is known and recorded in the RAW metadata, couldn’t HDR software automatically use one RAW file to generate the best under- and over-exposed versions and build the HDR image without manual busywork?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
12y ago
2 Answers
5
There's no need to create several exposures from a raw file to do this, you don't create any extra information. You can simply load the raw file straight into Photomatix and apply the settings as normal.
The reason cameras don't do this automatically is that not everyone likes the look that tonemapping provides, particularly the halos around high contrast edges.
Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user1375
12y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
A single RAW can often be used directly in HDR software, and many tools already do this without needing you to make multiple JPEGs first. But creating several “exposures” from one RAW does not add new image information—it only remaps the same captured data.
That’s the key limit: a true HDR composite gains dynamic range by combining multiple shots exposed differently, so each frame captures different parts of the scene without clipping highlights or crushing shadows. One RAW only contains the range the sensor recorded in that one exposure. You can recover some shadows/highlights from it, but you cannot exceed what was captured.
So:
- single RAW HDR/tone mapping = useful for processing convenience and style
- multi-exposure HDR = useful when the scene’s dynamic range exceeds what one frame can capture
Also, cameras/software don’t always do this automatically because tone mapping is a creative choice, and many photographers dislike the typical HDR look or artifacts such as halos.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI12y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How are RAW files tone-mapped for camera and Lightroom previews?
Can a single RAW file replace bracketed exposures for HDR?
Why do bright highlights lose detail on a Nikon D700, even when shooting RAW?
Should you still expose RAW images to the right, or avoid clipping highlights?
Why can some cameras recover more highlight detail from RAW files than others?