Can Google Photos back up my Apple Photos library without affecting iCloud Photos?

Asked 9/27/2016

3 views

2 answers

0

I use Apple Photos on iPhone and Mac with iCloud Photos, and I want to keep that setup. I’m considering enabling Google Photos backup on iPhone as a second cloud backup.

If I do that, how does it interact with Apple Photos?

  • Does Google Photos make its own local copy, or just upload from the photos already on the device?
  • If I delete a photo in Google Photos, does it also delete it from Apple Photos/iCloud?
  • Can I organize the same backed-up photos into separate albums in Google Photos?
  • If I edit a photo in Apple Photos, will Google Photos reflect that change automatically?

I’m asking about normal backup behavior only, not the separate “free up space” feature.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

1

The cloud back up would happen as the following.

  1. Only your local photos would be copied to the cloud.
  2. Google photos / Apple Photos, Backs up your local images, They make a copy in the cloud, So as long you have the local photo there may be a copy in both, Google and Apple photo.
  3. If you delete de image in your phone you may still have it on the cloud, However if you delete the image from the cloud, They may ask you if you want to delete this file completly.
  4. IF you delete the image from Google photos, Apple will have the cloud backup since they are different apps, however in order to delete a picture you have to go to each individually.
  5. If you edit a picture in the cloud, Then wont be backed however if you save it as a new file this would have to be backed up again, Which means that could create a new image, Making tedious to delete the original copy which would still being in both. (Edits and need to change it for a new name)

Think of it on this way if you delete any picture from your phone you may need to delete it from both, Google and Apple photo in order to erase it completly.

IF you delete it from any them, Google or Apple photo, One could delete the image, But you may still have one copy. Either Apple or Google but never locally since they erase the picture often from both, The cloud and locally.

[Phone] - > [Google] * [Apple]

Hope it helps.

Originally by user57045. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user57045

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—Google Photos can be used as a separate backup alongside Apple Photos/iCloud.

In normal use, Google Photos uploads photos it can access on your device to Google’s cloud; it does not need to replace or move them out of Apple Photos. Think of it as making another cloud copy from the local photos on the phone.

Deletion is generally separate: deleting a photo from Google Photos does not automatically delete it from Apple Photos/iCloud, because they are different services. If you want a photo gone from both, you typically delete it in both places.

Organization can also be separate. Google Photos can have its own albums and structure independent of Apple Photos.

Edits are not guaranteed to stay in sync across services. If you change a photo in Apple Photos, Google Photos should not be assumed to update that same cloud copy automatically. In practice, a newly saved edited version may be treated like a new file that would need to be backed up again.

So, broadly, your expectation is reasonable: Google Photos can serve as an additional backup, but edits, deletions, and organization should be treated as independent unless you verify behavior in the app.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer