Can different lenses affect white balance or color in photos?

Asked 8/2/2019

110 views

2 answers

0

I’ve noticed that Auto White Balance seems to give different results when I switch between a wide-angle lens and a macro lens. Does white balance actually change from lens to lens, or is this more likely due to differences in light transmission, scene coverage, or exposure?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

1

Modern lenses are fabricated using an array of single element lenses. Some elements are air-spaced, some are glued together. Such a design is necessary because a single element lens suffers from a minimum of seven optical defects we call aberrations. In theory, it would take seven individual lens elements to counter these aberrations. Such an aberration free has never been achieved. Lens makers try there best, some high quality camera lens contain more than a dozen individual lens elements.

These lens elements are different as to their shape plus they are not flawlessly as to transparency. Some color is naturally inherent in the glass. Additionally, each element has two polished surfaces that reflect light. Thus as the image forming light rays traverse each element will reflect away about 2 to 3% of the wanted light. A high percentage of this stray reflected light will intermingle with the image forming light rays. This degrades the image by lowering contrast and contributing to ghost images and flare light.

The counter measure for unwanted reflections is lens coating. Each lens element is coated with a transparent covering of a specific mineral. It’s a combination of thickness and material that does this trick. The coat reduces the amount of light reflected. A single coat is specific for one color of light. A modern lens will have multiple coats, one of each color that needs to be controlled.

Bottom line, the fact that a lens consist of multiple lens elements, each with a mineral coat, adds unwanted color to the image. This tint will be compounded by the scene lighting. Often the results of a picture taking session are less than faithful because we humans see with an eye / brain combination. This human trait is imitated by the white balance routine driven by computer logic built-in the camera. When we mount a lens, its color qualities will comingle with the scene color qualities. White balance to the rescue.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—different lenses can influence the color reaching the sensor, so images may look slightly warmer, cooler, or tinted from one lens to another. Glass types, coatings, and overall light transmission can all affect color fidelity a bit.

That said, your Auto White Balance can also change simply because the camera is analyzing a different scene. A wide-angle lens includes much more of the environment, while a macro lens often sees a very small, specific subject area. Since Auto WB estimates color from what it sees through the lens, changing the framing can easily change the WB result even under the same lighting.

So the difference you’re seeing is likely a combination of:

  • small color/transmission differences between lenses
  • Auto WB reacting differently to different compositions
  • possible exposure/transmission differences

If you want consistent results, use a fixed white balance or custom white balance instead of Auto WB when comparing lenses.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer