Can converting RAW files to DNG cause color corruption or image data loss?
Asked 3/14/2016
1 views
2 answers
0
I converted Sigma DP1x .X3F RAW files to .DNG with Adobe DNG Converter. Most files looked fine, but a few showed severe red/green color problems after conversion. The original .X3F files rendered correctly in Sigma Photo Pro, while the converted .DNG files showed the same issue in both darktable and RawTherapee.
Can RAW-to-DNG conversion damage image data, or is this more likely a rendering/conversion bug?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
10y ago
2 Answers
2
Any application can have a bug, misconfiguration or hit a problem, apps that do image conversions are no different; that appears to be what you've encountered here.
There's no huge benefit to converting raw files to DNG, any type of conversion (even one billed as lossless) has to modify the content in some way (or why bother with it?) so the best thing to do is avoid conversions where there is no need to do them.
The best thing to do now would be restore the raw files from your backup, ditch the DNG files and not to worry about DNG conversion in future.
Originally by user14028. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user14028
10y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, a RAW-to-DNG conversion can introduce problems if the converter or the software reading the DNG has a bug or misinterprets the file. What you’re seeing is unlikely to be normal "degradation" from DNG itself, especially not such extreme color shifts.
In general, lossless DNG conversion should not alter the underlying image data in a visible way. Severe red/green corruption points more toward a conversion or rendering issue than ordinary quality loss.
Since the original X3F files render correctly in Sigma Photo Pro, the safest conclusion is that either Adobe DNG Converter or the software decoding those DNGs is mishandling some Sigma files.
Practical takeaway: keep your original RAW files, restore from backup if needed, and avoid converting to DNG unless you have a clear reason to do so. If your original files work properly in the manufacturer’s software, they remain the best reference for correct rendering.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI10y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Does converting a camera RAW file to DNG perform irreversible demosaicing?
Does converting a DNG/RAW file to TIFF in Camera Raw or Photoshop apply gamma?
Can I remove the embedded JPEG preview from iPhone DNG files so macOS Preview shows the RAW image?
Will converting Sony ARW files to DNG lose metadata or useful maker notes?
How can I detect corrupted Canon CR2 raw files in a large archive?