Can a split-prism focusing aid work if it’s installed off-center in a DSLR focusing screen?
Asked 12/1/2018
2 views
2 answers
0
I’ve seen DIY modifications where a surplus split-prism focusing screen is trimmed to fit a modern DSLR, but these often cause metering issues. If the split-prism area were placed in a corner instead of the center—so it stays away from the spot-metering area—would it still work as a manual-focus aid? Or would the off-center position cause problems because of the focusing screen’s Fresnel pattern or because the lens effectively appears slower toward the edge?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
7y ago
2 Answers
3
An off-center split prism should work fine to assist manual focusing at the spot it's located. Lens resolution tends to drop off toward the edges. So the farther off-center the focus point, the lower the resolution at which you'll be able to focus. You can still fallback on autofocus if your lens supports it because the autofocus sensor is behind the mirror and not affected by the focusing screen.
Whether a modified focusing screen will affect other functions depends on the location of the sensors with respect to the focusing screen. On a Canon EOS 550D, for instance, the autofocus sensor is behind the mirror, and the light-meter sensor is behind the focusing screen, so using a focusing screen that transmits less light than the original will result in over exposure, while a focusing screen that transmits more light will result in underexposure.
A split prism over the center spot meter may affect readings by reducing light transmission or changing the path that light would normally take if the prism weren't there. It may not be significant if the difference is only a fraction of a stop.
Originally by user75526. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user75526
7y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes—an off-center split prism can still work as a manual-focus aid at the part of the frame where it’s located.
The main tradeoff is image quality toward the edges: lenses usually resolve less detail off-center, so focusing precision may be lower the farther the prism is from the middle. It can still be useful, just potentially less exact.
It may also affect metering, depending on how your camera is designed. In many DSLRs, autofocus is handled by a separate sensor behind the mirror, so AF operation is typically not affected by the focusing screen. Metering can be affected if the meter reads light after it passes through the focusing screen; a replacement screen that transmits more or less light than the original can shift exposure.
So, in principle, placing the split prism away from the spot-metering area can help avoid interfering with that specific metering region, but overall behavior still depends on where your camera’s metering sensor reads from and how the modified screen transmits light.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI7y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Do modern DSLRs still have focusing screens, and can you add manual-focus aids?
Can you get an off-center split-image focusing screen for an SLR to avoid focus-and-recompose errors?
Can I swap DSLR focusing screens regularly, and what precautions should I take?
Why don’t most DSLRs use split-prism or microprism focusing screens?
Why is manual focus inaccurate after installing a split-prism focusing screen on my Nikon D5100?