Can a minor drop affect autofocus calibration in the camera body, the lens, or both?

Asked 1/26/2013

3 views

2 answers

0

I dropped a Canon 6D with a 35mm f/1.4 lens attached from about 45 cm (18 in) onto carpet. It still works, but I’m wondering how a bump or drop could affect autofocus calibration.

What parts of an SLR autofocus system can be knocked out of alignment? I can imagine the lens having moving parts that might shift, but can the camera body itself also develop AF issues from impact? If so, what is actually moving or going out of alignment inside the body?

I’m not mainly asking for repair advice; I’m trying to understand the mechanics of how autofocus alignment works and how impact damage could cause front- or back-focus, reduced sharpness, or uneven focus across the frame.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

3

Wow, there are so many things that can be affected... Assuming there is damage (an 18" drop onto carpet isn't likely to have damaged anything, but it's possible) the most likely situation might be a warping of the lens mount so that the mount isn't parallel with the sensor (either the focus sensor or the main imaging sensor). The focus sensor would focus on one point, but another point at the same distance elsewhere on the sensor might be out of focus. Here and here are nice writeups with interactive graphics illustrating the two most common types of SLR autofocus systems.

Although somewhat broad, here is a comprehensive set of slides covering autofocussing/focus mechanisms that I find incredibly interesting...

To check your focus you can do a 'brick wall' test to see if focus is consistent across a parallel field. You can also do an 'autofocus' test to check front/back focus.

Originally by user11772. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user11772

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes—either the lens, the body, or both can be affected by a drop, although an 18-inch drop onto carpet may well cause no damage at all.

Autofocus problems after impact are not necessarily “all or nothing.” In an SLR, AF accuracy depends on precise alignment between the lens mount, the AF sensor system, and the imaging sensor. A shock can slightly shift or warp parts so they are no longer perfectly aligned. One common issue is the lens mount no longer sitting exactly parallel to the sensor plane, which can cause focus errors or uneven sharpness across the frame.

The lens can also be affected because it contains moving optical/focus groups and mechanical assemblies that can be knocked out of alignment.

A practical check is to separate optical sharpness from AF accuracy:

  • Use a tripod and a fine-detail target.
  • Test manual focus first to find the true sharpest point.
  • Then repeat with autofocus and compare.
  • A flat subject like a brick wall can also reveal whether focus is consistent across the frame.

If manual focus images are sharp but AF is consistently off, that points more to AF alignment. If nothing is very sharp, lens/body alignment or optical damage is more likely.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer