Can a MacBook Pro Retina display be calibrated accurately for photo editing?
Asked 3/31/2013
4 views
2 answers
0
I’m considering a MacBook Pro with Retina display for photo work, but I’ve heard its screen can look darker and more contrasty than prints. I already use a Spyder 3 Elite with an Eizo monitor and want to know whether the Retina display can be calibrated properly, especially with a Spyder device. Has anyone had success matching it to another calibrated monitor or getting more reliable print-to-screen consistency?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
4
Yes it can be calibrated using the proper hardware. I have a retina display macbook and also a Spyder Elite 3, and I can calibrate it to match my 23" desktop monitor.
The result is pretty close, side-by-side, the colours are almost identical.
Inaccurate default settings of the Macbook
This is true. You were also right about the high contrast. I was stupid enough to carry out some adjustments on about 200 photos on my macbook before I ran the calibration. Most photos turned out to be quite washed out (to a point where it looks fake and horribly photoshopped) on my calibrated 23" desktop monitor.
By default, it renders black much darker than what it should be, so I had to lighten it up using the "Shadow" slider in Lightroom 4.
In terms of colours, it is pretty accurate by default. However with the unreasonably high contrast, I feel that properly calibrating it is an absolute must if you intend to do any photographic work on it.
Since I have invested in a Spyder, I stopped trying free/software solutions. I have searched for free alternatives, however I snatched a Spyder when it was on sale and discovered that the best free/software calibrating tool is nowhere near remotely accurate.
Easily one of the best piece of tool that gives me identically accurate colour rendition across multiple computers laptops and monitors. It is not even that expensive just around $100.
Originally by user6745. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user6745
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — a MacBook Pro Retina display can be calibrated, including with a Spyder 3 Elite, and users report it can be matched fairly closely to a calibrated desktop monitor.
The main issue mentioned is not that calibration is impossible, but that the Retina display’s default appearance may look overly contrasty, with blacks/shadows rendered too dark. That can lead to edits that later look washed out on a properly calibrated display or in print.
A hardware calibrator is the right approach. If your Spyder works with your system/software, it should help bring the display much closer to accurate. Users have reported near-identical color side-by-side with a calibrated external monitor after calibration.
If prints still don’t match, calibration may not be the only factor: printer/paper gamut and correct ICC printer profiles also matter. Soft-proofing with the printer profile is important, because some screen colors simply can’t be reproduced in print.
So: yes, it’s usable for photo editing, but expect the default profile/contrast to need correction, and verify your print workflow with proper printer ICC profiles as well.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How does a monitor calibration device like the Spyder 3 work?
Why can an external monitor look better with the generic sRGB profile than its built-in ICC profile?
What gamut and backlight settings should I choose for a MacBook Pro Retina display in Spyder calibration software?
Why does a calibrated monitor look oversaturated, while my prints come back dull?
How can I calibrate a MacBook Pro display so prints match what I see on screen?