Can a 150x150mm polarizing sheet work as a temporary camera filter?

Asked 6/15/2018

3 views

2 answers

0

I found a 150x150mm polarizing filter sheet/gel and the seller says people use it for photography. I’m on a tight budget and plan to buy a proper polarizing filter later, especially since large 150x150mm filters are expensive. As a temporary workaround, can a polarizing sheet be used in front of a lens? If so, what are the limitations compared with a proper photographic polarizer?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

2

The polarizing filter mounts in front of the camera lens and should be optically flat. In other words, both surfaces should be parallel with the same thickness throughout. In many ways, an optically flat filter is more difficult to make than a simple lens. If not optically flat, it will degrade image quality. Luckily, most of the time, the distortions introduced are minuscule.

Most modern DSLR cameras use polarization as part of their built-in auto-focus and exposure metering systems. Because of this, a polarizing filter can interfere with these functions. Cameras that focus using contrast detection are not affected.

To avoid causing problems, there are circular polarizing filters, which are actually two filters sandwiched together. The first is a standard "linear" polarizing filter, which does the polarizing for us. The second filter, called a "retarder", scrambles the polarization so it won't interfere with the camera's autofocus and exposure metering.

I have never had any equipment harmed by a linear polarizing filter, and I doubt you will see any significant difference in image quality. Go for it. Then when your budget allows, get a circular polarizer to replace it.

Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user44949

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes, it can work to some extent, but it’s a compromise.

A polarizing sheet can reduce reflections and deepen skies like a normal polarizer, but for camera use the material should be optically flat and uniform. If it isn’t, it can soften the image or introduce distortion. A loose “gel” or film may also need to be mounted onto something rigid, such as clear plastic or glass, to stay flat.

Another limitation is that many DSLR autofocus and metering systems use polarized light internally. A simple linear polarizer can interfere with AF or exposure metering on those cameras. Proper circular polarizing filters are designed to avoid that issue. Cameras using contrast-detect autofocus are generally less affected.

So: as a very low-cost, temporary experiment, a polarizing sheet may be usable, especially if mounted flat. But expect lower durability, possible image-quality loss, and possible AF/metering problems versus a proper circular polarizing filter.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer