Are mirrorless cameras more prone to sensor dust than DSLRs?

Asked 2/24/2019

3 views

2 answers

0

When changing lenses, a mirrorless camera often has the sensor area more exposed than a DSLR, which has a mirror box and shutter in front of the sensor. Does that make mirrorless cameras more susceptible to dust getting onto the sensor in normal use?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

7y ago

2 Answers

5

The air is full of dust. It's floating around everywhere all the time. When you open the lens in a dusty environment (which is to say "every environment that isn't a clean room"), dust gets into the light-box of the camera.

You didn't ask, but this is why seems silly to advise people to point their cameras down while changing lenses. Observe how dust moves in the air: it falls down gradually, eventually, but mostly it responds to air currents going up, down, left, right, wherever. If you're in an especially dusty situation, the important thing is fast.

The risk isn't really that dust might fall right on the sensor while it's exposed. It's that dust floating around will eventually settle there and stick. As the question you link notes, the shutter itself doesn't protect much against this, since it opens "violently", scattering dust around.

In fact, arguably, the larger mirror box in a DSLR is just more space for dust to drift around in waiting to cause a problem. I don't know if that's a real-world issue, though. In my experience, the automatic dust-removal systems all cameras now include have become very good in the last decade.

The one thing I know for sure is that having the sensor closer to the opening makes it easier to clean once some problematic dust does build up. So, advantage mirrorless for that, at least.

Originally by user1943. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1943

7y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes, generally mirrorless cameras are somewhat more susceptible to sensor dust because there is less physical shielding in front of the sensor area during lens changes. On many mirrorless bodies, the sensor is effectively more exposed than in a DSLR, where the mirror box and shutter provide some barrier.

That said, dust risk is not just about particles falling directly onto the sensor at the moment of a lens change. Dust is already in the air and can enter the camera whenever the mount is open, then later settle and stick inside. So the shutter alone is not a complete defense.

In practice, the difference is real but manageable. Features that help include:

  • shutter-closing behavior on some cameras when powered off
  • ultrasonic sensor-cleaning systems
  • weather sealing
  • lenses with internal focusing, which tend to move less air than extending zooms

The most useful habit is to change lenses quickly, especially in dusty environments.

UniqueBot

AI

7y ago

Your Answer