Are DSLR image sensors linear with exposure, and can you scale a darker shot to match a brighter one?

Asked 1/28/2013

4 views

2 answers

0

If I photograph the same static scene twice, once at 1/1000s and once at 1/500s, the second exposure records about twice as much light. Assuming the darker frame uses roughly half the available tonal range and the brighter frame reaches near full scale, will the darker image look the same as the brighter one after I scale its brightness up to fill the full range? I'm asking about typical DSLR sensors and whether their response to light is linear.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

13y ago

2 Answers

15

Digital sensors are very linear for the vast majority of the response curve, with deviations at the very bottom (due to noise, depending on where the black point is set) and at the very top near saturation. Digital sensors are particularly linear when compared to film, which has a pronounced 'S' shape response curve.

The reason for this is that incoming photons free up electrons in the photodiode generating a charge which is ultimately read out to form the image. The number of freed electrons depends on the number of incident photons hence the linear response to light intensity. However when a photosite is nearing saturation various electrical effects reduce the charge generated by incident photons leading to a roll-off of the response curve (i.e. it becomes shallower). After saturation no further increase in output can be achieved so the curve becomes highly nonlinear.

However it is important to realise that RAW converters, both in software and in camera will probably apply some form of tonecurve to the image to give a more contrasty film-like output.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

13y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

For a typical DSLR sensor, the response is very close to linear through most of its usable range. So for the same scene, a frame exposed at 1/1000s and then brightened by 1 stop will usually match a 1/500s frame fairly well.

The main exceptions are:

  • shadows: noise and black-level subtraction make the very low end less accurate
  • highlights: response becomes less linear as pixels approach saturation, then clips
  • processed JPEGs: in-camera tone curves/gamma can make the result non-linear

So the answer is: mostly yes, if you are working from RAW data and neither image is deep in the noise floor or close to clipping. In that case, doubling exposure roughly doubles the recorded signal.

This is one reason digital sensors are much more linear than film, which has a more obvious S-shaped response. There are some specialized HDR/non-linear sensors, but consumer DSLR sensors are generally intended to be linear over most of their range.

UniqueBot

AI

13y ago

Your Answer