Are 3 bracketed exposures usually enough for HDR landscapes?

Asked 8/8/2016

3 views

2 answers

0

I'm new to photography and use a Canon 550D / Rebel T2i, which can auto-bracket 3 shots. For HDR, are 3 exposures usually enough to capture a scene's full brightness range, especially for landscapes like beaches or sunsets? I realize it depends on the scene, but I'm looking for a general rule of thumb so I can plan ahead when I don't get many chances to revisit a location. If 3 shots often aren't enough, I can add more exposures manually.

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

9y ago

2 Answers

11

It all depends on the scene in terms of overall brightness, the total dynamic range, and how fine the graduations are between bright and dark.

The wider the difference is between the brightest part and the darkest part of the scene, the further apart your darkest and brightest exposures need to be.

The best way to measure this is to use your camera's smallest metering circle (usually called "spot metering") and compare the recommended exposure values between metering the brightest part of the scene and metering the darkest part of the scene. How many stops difference are there?

Once you have determined how far apart your darkest and brightest exposures need to be then you can decide how many exposures you need based upon the maximum step size between exposures. If your scene is mostly very bright and very dark with no gradual transitions then you can probably get by with larger steps. Something in the range of 2 or even 3 stops between exposures will probably be enough. If the scene has a lot of gradual transitions from bright to dark then you will need the steps between exposures to be smaller. Differences in the range of 1 stop or even less will give the best results.

Since your camera's dynamic range is usually only maximized at base ISO, it also depends on the ISO setting you are using. As you raise the ISO, your camera's DR will be reduced so you will need to use smaller steps between each exposure to capture the same amount of information. For a wide dynamic range scene you can still usually get all of the mid-tones without any gaps by shooting a -2, 0, +2 or even -3, 0, +3 series if you are shooting at fairly low ISO (around ISO 400 or less) and center your base exposure value properly. At higher ISO settings you may need to shoot a -3, -1, +1, +3 series or even a full series separated by only one stop.

Be aware that a single 14-bit raw file may contain as much dynamic range information as a a -3, 0, +3 series of 8-bit JPEGs! So shooting a series of raw shots bracketed at -1, 0, +1 includes a lot of overlap, even with digital cameras that can only capture 10-11 stops of dynamic range. The best cameras today can go as high as 13-14 stops at base ISO. Those same cameras at around ISO 3200 are down to around 10 stops of dynamic range. Not only does this affect the maximum difference between the brightest and darkest details that they can record but it also reduces the smallest step size in brightness that they can differentiate. So a sky that is bright on one side of the frame and dark on the other side will show smoother transition from light to dark at lower ISO. At higher ISO you have a greater risk of getting banding in the same transition.

Originally by user15871. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user15871

9y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Usually, yes: 3 bracketed exposures are often enough for HDR, and sometimes even 2 are sufficient. But there is no fixed number that works for every scene.

What matters is the scene’s dynamic range: the difference between the brightest highlights and the darkest shadows. If that range is modest, 3 shots will usually cover it well. If it’s extreme, you may need more frames.

A practical way to judge this is to spot-meter the brightest important area and the darkest important area, then compare the exposure difference in stops. That tells you how wide a bracket you need.

In theory, a few exposures can cover a lot of range, but in practice more shots can help when:

  • the scene has very deep shadows and bright highlights
  • you want cleaner shadow detail
  • long exposures cause blur from wind or movement
  • higher ISO reduces usable dynamic range

Also, extra shots give diminishing returns. Most landscape scenes, including many sunsets and beaches, can be handled well with 3 frames if spaced appropriately. If the contrast looks extreme, take extra manual exposures to be safe.

UniqueBot

AI

9y ago

Your Answer