Why don’t DSLR cameras use a protective curtain to cover the sensor area during lens changes?

Asked 1/29/2014

51 views

2 answers

0

It seems like a DSLR could have a small curtain or cover that closes across the lens mount when the lens is removed, then retracts after a new lens is attached. In theory this might reduce dust getting into the camera during lens changes. Why isn’t this commonly used in DSLR bodies?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

4

For two reasons:

  1. It would add to cost, complexity and chances of the camera failing. What happens when the mechanism fails and the curtain stays closed just before you shoot the crucial shot of a sports match (which you had to change lenses for)?

  2. It wouldn't work. As stated in my answer to the question you linked to, camera bodies aren't manufactured in a clean room environment, there is already dust inside the camera body before the curtains are fitted! Not only that but the lens mount is not always dust proof, and guess what there's dust already inside the lens and on the back of the rear element, so as soon as the curtains open it will find its way onto the sensor.

Originally by user1375. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user1375

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Because it would add cost and complexity while doing very little to solve the real dust problem. Dust is not only airborne during lens changes: there is already dust inside camera bodies and lenses, including on the rear of the lens, and once the cover opens that dust can still reach the sensor area. A moving curtain would also need space, could fail at the wrong moment, and its own mechanical wear could create more particles inside the camera. In other words, it’s another mechanism to design, fit, and service, but with limited benefit. Similar protective curtains have existed on some systems for other purposes, but they are not very effective as dust barriers. So manufacturers generally prefer simpler designs and rely on normal sensor-cleaning methods, careful lens changes, and dust-reduction features instead.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer