What does Lightroom catalog backup do beyond copying the .lrcat file?

Asked 10/18/2017

33 views

2 answers

0

When Lightroom creates a catalog backup, is it doing more than just copying the .lrcat file, assuming Optimize Catalog is turned off? Manual copying of my .lrcat takes only a few seconds, but Lightroom’s backup takes much longer. If my normal backup system already copies the catalog file regularly, is there any benefit to also using Lightroom’s built-in catalog backup?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

4

The Lightroom catalog backup does multiple things, generally: does an integrity check on the catalog (why back up something if it is corrupt), copies the file, and optimizes the running copy for better performance. I am fairly sure during the optimization that it does a cleanup of (some? all?) preview files. And finally it zips the catalog's backup to save space.

Should you decide to copy it, be absolutely sure that Lightroom does not have it open, as copying a changing copy of the SQLite database is not safe.

The Lightroom catalog backup is a good idea to have point in time catalogs to recover in the event of catalog corruption or user error.

The backups your backup system are somewhat redundant to the catalog backups, provided you do them regularly and also keep multiple versions. But they are not a substitute for periodically doing the optimize step, nor the integrity check. A mixture of both is the best idea.

Originally by user28109. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user28109

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes. Lightroom’s catalog backup is more than a simple file copy. Based on the community answers, it typically includes an integrity check on the catalog, copies the catalog, may optimize the working catalog for performance, and stores the backup as a zipped file to save space. That extra work explains why it takes longer than manually copying the .lrcat file.

A manual copy can still be useful, but only if Lightroom is fully closed. The catalog is an SQLite database, so copying it while Lightroom has it open is not considered safe.

If your regular backup system keeps multiple versions and runs consistently, it overlaps with Lightroom’s backup quite a bit. The main advantage of Lightroom’s own backup is having point-in-time catalog copies that can help if the catalog becomes corrupted or if you need to recover from user error. In short: your external backups may be sufficient if they are versioned and reliable, but Lightroom’s built-in backup adds a convenient extra layer of protection.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer