What caused the horizontal line across the moon in this telephoto shot?

Asked 2/5/2018

26 views

2 answers

0

In a telephoto photo/video of the blood moon aligned with the tip of a Saturn V mockup, a thin horizontal line appears across the moon near the rocket tip. The photographer reported that it showed up on multiple cameras, including video, but only from one of the two shooting locations. Gear included a Canon 70D with a 300mm lens, a Panasonic GH5 with a 100mm lens, and a Canon 7D Mark II.

What is the most likely cause of this line: something in the cameras/sensors, an object in the scene, or an optical effect related to the rocket tip/beacon?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

4

My best guess is that it's a trail from a passenger jet flying through the scene, as it looks a bit uneven and inconsistent. That would also make sense given that only cameras from that site picked it up.

Investigating the contrail hypothesis - some planes were close to the sight line and in a theoretical range (no wonder... planes are everywhere).

wwww.flightradar24.com replay showing the approximate direction and distances: Flightradar replay

Visibility range calculated for a typical airliner altitude between 25000 feet (orange) and 35000 feet (blue) - generated on the heywhatsthat.com website visibility range

Originally by user24522. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user24522

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Most likely it was not a sensor/CMOS artifact. Because it appeared on multiple cameras and in video, the cause was probably in the scene or in the optical path from that one location.

The strongest explanation from the community is an aircraft contrail or wake crossing the line of sight to the moon. The line looks uneven rather than perfectly uniform, and the fact that only one shooting location recorded it fits a localized atmospheric/object-in-the-distance explanation.

A secondary possibility is an optical effect from the warning beacon/lens at the rocket tip. A cylindrical protective lens can refract or diffract bright light and create a line-like flare along one axis, especially with the moon aligned closely behind it.

So the best answer is: it was probably a contrail or aircraft wake, with a beacon-lens diffraction/refraction effect as another plausible explanation. It is unlikely to be a DSLR/CMOS readout issue, since different cameras saw the same thing.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer