Is it safe to retract a zoom lens by pushing on the lens hood instead of turning the zoom ring?

Asked 12/1/2019

101 views

2 answers

0

On my 18-135mm DX f/3.5-5.6 lens, I noticed I can retract the lens by gently pushing it back toward the camera while holding the lens hood, instead of twisting the zoom ring. I’m not forcing it hard, just applying light pressure. Is this generally safe for the lens mechanism, or could it cause wear or damage over time?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

6y ago

2 Answers

14

We are presumably talking about a purely mechanically linked zoom here. The lens groups and shafts run in threaded gear tracks. What you are doing here is reversing the operation, pushing a shaft to make its gear track turn and move all of the other groups/gears in turn. The respective mechanical elements and tracks are not designed to work this way round: it's a bit like trying to turn a screw by pushing a nut on it. In theory, that's in some way an invertible operation but in practice you are not going to do your threads a favor.

In the best case, you'll put much more of a load than usual on the respective pins moving the lens shaft, making the positioning of it and its affixed elements/groups lose precision in a smaller amount of time than the lens has been designed for.

Few compact cameras contain mechanically linked zoom: making the comparatively small components reliably survive regular human operation and irregular human operation comes at a cost in complexity and materials that may be more than a zoom motor actually weighs in at.

In short: just seems like a bad idea asking for trouble along the road.

Originally by user88221. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user88221

6y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Usually, no—it’s not a good habit unless the lens is specifically designed to work that way.

On most mechanically linked zoom lenses, the zoom ring moves internal cams, tracks, and guide pins in the direction they were designed to be driven. Pushing the barrel inward from the front reverses that load path, which can put extra stress on those parts and increase wear or reduce precision over time.

Some lenses are intentionally designed for push-pull use, or are loose enough that gravity can move the barrel without fighting gearing. In those cases, it may be less of an issue. But for a typical zoom lens, especially one not advertised as push-pull, it’s safer to use the zoom ring normally.

If the lens uses any non-direct or motor-assisted zoom mechanism, pushing it manually could be even more risky.

Best advice: check the lens manual or ask the manufacturer. If they don’t explicitly support it, avoid doing it regularly.

UniqueBot

AI

6y ago

Your Answer