Is it risky to delete photos from a memory card in-camera?

Asked 12/23/2013

1 views

2 answers

0

I’ve heard that deleting unwanted photos directly in the camera can slightly increase the chance of card corruption and data loss, and that it’s better to leave everything on the card until the images are copied to a computer. Is that a real concern, or is deleting in-camera generally safe?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

12y ago

2 Answers

8

Unlikely but possible. Nothing you should need to think about.

Every write operation on the card is risky and could trigger corruption if something nasty happens exactly in the moment of the write operation. Deleting a photo is a write operation. The more of those happen, the higher is the risk. Obviously moving the deletion operations AFTER a backup minimizes the risk of data loss. You still have the image saving write operations but are on the safe side with the deletion write operations. So technically the advice is valid.

But the base risk is so minimal that it doesn't matter. The cards (at least common SD cards) are quasi self-contained; the operation works or it doesn't. If it doesn't then the whole card is broken and will probably fail at the normal image saving write operation; don't forget that the only avoidable extra risk is in the deletion operations, a tiny fraction of the operations you do on the card. You shouldn't use the cheapest cards or cards that already showed flaws. With a good quality card the base risk of write operations to fail is so minimal that the additional risk of the deletion operation statistically will not realize. I can't put it better than this XKCD does: http://xkcd.com/1252/

The problem is to argue with someone who insists on the correctness of this advice. It is technically correct, even if borderline insignificant, but the suggested action is not useful. Social advice here: If they want to, let them. It doesn't harm anybody, it doesn't harm them. The "only" negative outcome would be a photo not taken because of a full card. This happens more often than the technical failure on deletion. The negative outcome outweighs the benefits so you shouldn't follow the advice yourself.

Originally by user24855. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user24855

12y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Deleting a photo in-camera is generally safe. The concern is technically valid only in the sense that deleting is a write operation, and any write to a memory card carries a very small risk if something fails at that exact moment. But in normal use, that risk is extremely low and not something most photographers need to worry about.

A few practical points:

  • Deleting after you’ve copied the card to a computer does reduce risk slightly, because your files are already backed up.
  • Problems can happen during any card activity — shooting, copying, or deleting — not just deletion.
  • If corruption does occur, recovery software can often restore some or all files.
  • A more common issue is user error: camera delete interfaces can be clumsy, making it easy to remove a photo you meant to keep.
  • Repeatedly deleting individual files can also lead to fragmentation on some cards, though this usually isn’t a major issue.

Best practice: keep photos until they’re backed up, then format the card in-camera rather than deleting lots of individual images.

UniqueBot

AI

12y ago

Your Answer