How can I migrate from Picasa to Lightroom without losing edits and metadata?
Asked 2/16/2016
4 views
2 answers
0
I have about 40,000 photos managed in the Windows desktop version of Picasa, including digital images and scanned film/family photos. Many files have Picasa edits such as crops and straightening, and I’d like to move to Lightroom now that Picasa is discontinued.
Since both programs use non-destructive editing, I’m trying to understand what can and cannot be carried over. Is it possible to bring Picasa edits into Lightroom while still keeping access to the original files? What happens to albums, ratings, tags, captions, and faces? If there isn’t a perfect transfer, what migration approach is safest?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
10y ago
2 Answers
9
I wrote a Lightroom plugin for migrating from Picasa to Lightroom. I searched all over the web and could not find a good solution, so I wrote one myself. I decided to polish it up and offer it for others to use for free. You run it from inside Lightroom and it imports all your Picasa Albums, people/faces, and star ratings. Your tags and captions will also be imported automatically. It's a one-time import procedure that only takes a few minutes. The instructions also explain how to save your Picasa edits (which is not automatic as implied by a posting in this thread).
The plugin is called P2Lr and you can find it along with instructions here: http://picasa-lightroom.com
I have tested the plugin on Windows and Mac, using the latest version of Picasa and Lightroom. I tested it using various test albums and my personal collection of over 33,000 photos. But other than that it has not been widely tested so it's considered beta at this point. If you use it, please let me know how it worked for you.
Note that an earlier post states that Lightroom automatically imports your Picasa folders. However Lightroom does NOT automatically import your Picasa "Albums" which are distinct from "Folders". Folders are simply the folders (or directories) on your disk. Albums are the separate collections you create using photos from your folders. Lightroom does not import the Picasa Albums. Nor does it import people and star ratings. The P2Lr plugin imports all of them.
Good luck! Let me know how it goes.
Originally by user58579. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user58579
9y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
You generally cannot transfer Picasa’s non-destructive edit history into Lightroom. The edit instructions are application-specific, so Lightroom won’t recreate them as editable Lightroom adjustments.
What you can do is preserve results and metadata:
- Picasa keeps originals, typically in subfolders near the edited files.
- If you import the existing folder structure into Lightroom without moving files, Lightroom may see both the edited file and the original, letting you keep both in the catalog and organize them with stacking if desired.
- Tags and captions can carry over if Picasa wrote them into file metadata, and Lightroom can read that metadata.
- A community plugin called P2Lr was created specifically to help import Picasa albums, people/faces, and star ratings into Lightroom.
Safest approach: back up everything first, then test on a small subset. If you want to preserve the visual result of Picasa edits, save/export those edited versions before or during migration, but expect the actual edit history to be lost. If keeping originals matters, make sure Lightroom imports the folder structure that includes them rather than replacing files blindly.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI10y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How can I preserve Picasa star selections so other photo software can read them?
What carries over when moving an iPhoto library to Lightroom 3?
Can Lightroom 3 edits be transferred to Bibble 5 for NEF raw files?
Software for organizing a large photo library without losing tags
Will captions from Photoshop Elements Organizer carry over to Lightroom?