Do 50mm mirror lenses exist, and what is the shortest practical focal length?
Asked 12/16/2017
95 views
2 answers
0
I enjoy the distinctive donut bokeh and quirks of mirror lenses, but I also like shooting around the normal 50mm field of view. Are there any true 50mm mirror lenses made for regular photography? If not, what is the shortest focal length that is practical or commonly available, and why are mirror lenses usually much longer telephoto designs?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
8y ago
2 Answers
22
The mirror lens design resolves two key optical problems:
All lenses suffer from chromatic aberration. This is color fringing due to the failure of the lens to refract (bend inward) all colors of light accurately. In a conventional lens, this is accomplished by sandwiching two or more lenses, of different powers using different recipes for the glass. The result is an achromatic (without color error) lens. The mirror lens avoids chromatic aberration because it uses a “first surface” mirror. The mirror coat is thus on the surface of the primary lens. This configuration evades chromatic aberration because the image forming light does not transverse the primary lens element. Chromatic aberration gets worse if the lens is a powerful telephoto. Thus mirror lenses are favored for super long focal length lenses.
The mirror lens folds the light path thus a long focal length can be accommodated by a shorter lens barrel.
The 50mm lens is only about 2 inches in focal length. Correcting chromatic aberration in such a short lens is a piece of cake. Lens designers would never attempt to fold a 50mm and make the barrel super short except for a very specialize application. Bottom line, you are not likely to find a find a 50mm mirror lens.
You like the bokeh! It is created by the fact that the mirror lens uses two mirrors. The secondary is up front. It is a small silvered circular mirror centered in the tubes entrance. You can experiment and obtain nearly the same bokeh with your existing 50mm. Mount a UV filter and glue an obstructing circle on it's center. Cut some opaque disks, different sizes and using double stick tape, and affix one to the center of the UV. Now make a shot or two and then try a different size opaque center blocker. You might like to know, some famous portrait lenses of the past used a center opaque obstacle.
Originally by user44949. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user44949
8y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
For normal photography, a true 50mm mirror lens is essentially not a practical/common product. Mirror (catadioptric) lenses are mainly used at long focal lengths, where their design gives a compact size and avoids chromatic aberration. At short focal lengths, their downsides become more significant: the central obstruction reduces light transmission and contrast, and it blocks the center of the image-forming area.
That is why mirror lenses are typically telephotos rather than normal or wide lenses. Extremely short mirror-based optics do exist in specialized fields like microscopy, but those are not conventional camera lenses. One answer also notes a patent example roughly equivalent to about 95mm full-frame, suggesting that even unusually wide mirror designs for cameras are still nowhere near 50mm and may only be feasible for mirrorless-style short back-focus systems.
So the practical answer is: you’re unlikely to find a standard 50mm mirror lens for interchangeable-lens photography. The closest discussed in the answers is around 95mm full-frame equivalent in a patent, while real-world mirror lenses are generally much longer.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI8y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Why are telephoto lens designs usually used for long focal lengths, not short ones?
Are there zoom macro lenses, and why are most macro lenses primes?
Are 500–800mm mirror lenses a good choice for DSLR astrophotography?
Why do mirror (catadioptric) lenses usually have a fixed aperture?
What’s the generic term for a long-focal-length lens if “telephoto” is a specific optical design?