Can you make a refractograph without removing the camera lens?
Asked 4/17/2013
56 views
2 answers
0
I saw a refractograph tutorial that says to remove the lens and let light patterns fall directly on the sensor. Is it possible to create a similar refractograph with a lens still attached? If so, what kind of lens would work best, and how would the results differ from shooting with no lens at all?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
6
No, or at least not directly, and not with the clarity and fine detail that you're seeing in the example images.
The image that is formed by a refractograph is the caustics of the light directly impinging on the sensor. You're probably more familiar with caustics from underwater pictures and film, where there are patterns of variation in the light falling on the subjects being photographed. With a refrectograph, your sensor (or film) is the object upon which those patterns are being cast. In a sense, the object you are taking the refractograph of is the lens.
In order to capture those patters using a focusing lens (whether that lens in in focus or not), they need to be falling on something that you can shoot. Whether you are shooting at a reflective opaque screen (a piece of very smooth, very reflective coated white paper) or through a transmissive screen (such as a one-side-matte mylar or acetate film or a ground glass focusing screen from an old camera) the screen itself will limit the dynamic range available to you, and probably add a bit of its own texture and reduce the detail quite a bit.
Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user2719
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes, but not in the same way and usually not with the same clarity or fine detail.
A refractograph records the caustic light patterns falling directly on the sensor or film. With no lens attached, those patterns hit the sensor itself. If you leave a lens on the camera, that lens becomes part of the refracting/optical system, adding its own focal length and altering the pattern.
So a lens-on setup can produce an effect, but it generally won’t match the look shown in tutorials that rely on direct light hitting the sensor. The extra optics tend to change the geometry and reduce the directness of the result.
There isn’t one specific lens type guaranteed to recreate the lens-off look. Any attached lens will influence the image, so experimentation is key. If your goal is the classic refractograph result, removing the lens is the more direct method.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago