Can I use a grey card and histogram instead of a flash meter for studio flash?
Asked 5/12/2013
44 views
2 answers
0
I’m learning studio/flash lighting and see many tutorials using a flash meter to set exposure and lighting ratios. I’d prefer not to buy one if I can avoid it. Can I fill the frame with a grey card, take a test shot, and use the histogram to judge flash exposure and ratios? Is there a way to relate the histogram position to stops, and does Magic Lantern on a Canon 60D help?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
6
Certainly. A flash meter is really (mostly) just a way to trade money for time. In my film days, a flash meter could save me literally hours compared to Polaroids on a complex shot (which translates to days using wet-processed film tests). With digital, and especially if you have remote control of your flash output, the time lost to exposure testing is insignificant. It's still not quite as quick as a flash meter, but it's now down to seconds or minutes lost at most (which can still be a significant time sink for a full-time working pro).
It will mean filling the frame (or at lest nearly filling it) with your exposure card, whether that's an ordinary grey card or a black/grey/white card. You'll need a lot of pixels to make a useful peak in the histogram, and if the card is too small in the frame, you may not be able to pick out the peak(s). There is no need, though, to try to guess where two stops up or one-and-a-half stops down fall on the tiny, uncalibrated histogram at the back of your camera; you just need to know where "normal" lives.
In the specific case you mentioned — overexposing a white background by two stops — you'd simply close your aperture down two stops and use the histogram to meter for "normal". When you open back up to your main subject exposure, the background will be two stops over. It only gets a little more complicated when you want to measure underexposure, and then only if you can't actually open the aperture far enough to measure — in that case, you'd need to adjust the camera's ISO higher by a corresponding amount (leaving your aperture at the main shooting aperture), then adjust flash output or reflector positions until you get a "normal" histogram. Again, once the camera is set back to its main subject shooting settings, the light you measured at "normal" will be underexposed by the desired amount.
In all of these cases, a tri-tone (black/grey/white) exposure card will be somewhat easier to use than a grey card, simply because the three peaks are easier to visually centre than the single peak of the grey card. And in all of these cases, you'll need to figure out where, for your camera and card, the exposure card's histogram peaks need to be for a "normal" exposure. But a little bit of testing up front to "clabrate" the camera/card system and a little extra time taken when setting up the shot will get you the functional equivalent of a flash meter.
Originally by user2719. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user2719
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Yes — with digital, a grey card plus test shots and the histogram can substitute for a flash meter, especially if you don’t mind spending a little more time. A flash meter mainly saves setup time.
To make this work:
- Fill most or all of the frame with the grey card so it creates a clear histogram peak.
- Be careful with the card angle. Flash is directional, so the reading changes with tilt. Hold the card so it reflects the light toward the camera, roughly midway between the light source angle and the camera axis.
- For lighting ratios, fire or test each light separately and compare the histogram peaks.
Limits:
- A histogram doesn’t directly label positions in stops, so you need to relate peak movement to your camera’s tonal range/dynamic range.
- The card must be large enough in frame; otherwise the peak can be lost in the rest of the scene.
- This method is slower and a bit less direct than using a flash meter, but for digital it’s usually practical.
So: yes, you can use a grey card effectively for flash exposure and ratio setup; a flash meter is mostly a speed/convenience tool.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
How do you set a 3:1 main-to-fill lighting ratio correctly?
How can I install Magic Lantern on additional SD cards and keep the same settings?
Can one SD card with Magic Lantern be used in both a Canon T5i/700D and T2i/550D?
Can I swap Magic Lantern CF cards between two Canon 7D bodies?
Can I install Magic Lantern on a Canon EOS Rebel T6i / 750D?