Can I reduce the appearance of safety netting in hockey photos?

Asked 10/29/2017

72 views

2 answers

0

I photographed a hockey game through the arena’s safety netting, and the mesh is visible in the images. Is there any practical way to reduce or remove the netting in post-processing? Also, are there shooting techniques that can help make the net less noticeable in future shots?

Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

Photography Stack Exchange contributor

8y ago

2 Answers

7

In post processing there is a way to try. Whether the result is less obstructive or not depends on your personal viewpoint, patience, skill and luck.

What you do is get an image processing application that can take a fourier transform of an image. I use GIMP with a plugin called G'MIC (which has a huge number of functions and is a must for GIMP users IMO). This has a fourier transform feature.

In the fourier transformed image you look for bright near regular patterns of dots and replace them with a small circle filled in the average background color of the fourier image.

You'll see loads of these in an image like yours.

When you've patiently done your work on the transformed image you then apply the inverse transform.

The final image will look like the netting was partially removed.

An example is shown here :

enter image description here

This was a quick attempt, but as you can see, while it does reasonably well at removing the netting, it also adds it's own artifacts. Whether these are more or less obstructive than the original is your own view.

When you transform the image you'll end us with this sort of thing (note I've done some of the corrections to this to show you ). This is a crop of teh transform of your own image :

enter image description here

Originally by user46861. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0

user46861

8y ago

0

AI Answer

Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.

Yes, but only to a limited extent. After the fact, netting is difficult to remove cleanly. One advanced post-processing approach is to use a Fourier transform in an editor that supports it (for example, via plugins in GIMP) and suppress the repeating pattern of the mesh, then apply the inverse transform. This can partially reduce the net, but results vary a lot and it takes patience and skill.

For future shots, the best fix is optical: use a telephoto lens with a very wide aperture and focus on the players/action so the netting, which is closer to you, falls out of focus and becomes much less noticeable. This works better when the net is well in front of the subject. If the netting is close in apparent distance to the players, there may be little you can do.

UniqueBot

AI

8y ago

Your Answer