Can any compact camera securely erase photos from its memory or card?
Asked 12/7/2012
3 views
2 answers
0
We need a compact camera for healthcare use and want the simplest way to remove patient photos after they are transferred to our network. Ideally the camera itself would securely erase images from the memory card, or perform a true wipe/format rather than just removing the file table. If built-in secure deletion is not realistic, are there practical camera-based alternatives that reduce the risk of recoverable files?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
13y ago
2 Answers
5
The closest you could get is to have a secure (encrypted) card so that the contents were scrambled to those who don't have the password.
Lexar produced a CF card range called LockTight, which offered encryption in combination with the Nikon D200 although I've seen nothing new on it in a few years.
I haven't heard much if anything about the technology for a few years but it's a starting point.
Edit: I should have mentioned that the encryption mechanism happens within the card rather than in camera/computer - which means the key management is not subject to the usual forensic recovery techniques which come about as a result of wear levelling.
Originally by user14028. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user14028
13y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
Built-in secure erase on compact cameras is uncommon, and on flash storage it may not be reliable anyway because of wear leveling. A normal in-camera delete or format usually just removes directory information, not all underlying data.
From the options mentioned, the most practical alternatives are:
- use encrypted storage, such as cards with onboard encryption, so recovered data is unreadable without the key
- use wireless transfer workflows to move images off-camera quickly
- use a camera’s internal memory instead of removable cards, then transfer and securely erase from a controlled system
One reported workflow was using Panasonic Lumix cameras with internal memory, transferring files over VPN to a network share, then securely deleting them via a simple batch process. That avoids handling removable cards and may be easier for staff.
So the short answer is: don’t expect a compact camera to offer trustworthy secure deletion by itself. For healthcare use, a better approach is encrypted storage or a controlled transfer-and-erase workflow using internal memory or managed external systems.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI13y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
Can an Eye-Fi card automatically upload photos at home, and does it delete files after transfer?
Can any cameras require a PIN before photos can be deleted?
How can a non-technical user print photos easily without using a computer?
How can two people track who shot each photo when sharing one camera?
Why don’t cameras use journaled filesystems on SD cards, and how can I reduce the risk of losing photos?