Are Neewer Q flashes the same as Godox, and are the systems compatible?
Asked 1/19/2024
79 views
2 answers
0
I've seen claims that some Neewer flash gear is just rebranded Godox equipment. For example, the Neewer Q3 looks similar to a Godox AD200 Pro, and the transmitters/flashes in Neewer's Q system look a lot like Godox X-system products. Are these actually the same products under different branding, or just similar designs? If I mix Neewer Q-system gear with Godox X-system gear, will they work together wirelessly?
Originally by Photography Stack Exchange contributor. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
Photography Stack Exchange contributor
2y ago
2 Answers
4
TLDR; No, they're not the same and they're not compatible.
The Neewer Q System is not the Godox X System
You are not the first person to see the physical similarity between Neewer's new "Q" system and Godox's "X" system. The Neewer QPro looks quite a bit like a Godox XPro; a Neewer Z1 has a round head and looks a lot like a Godox V1; and the Neewer Q3 is aping an AD200 Pro. But the UIs are different on the flashes and transmitters, and the Q3's head is fixed, not interchangeable.
There are, in fact, a number of different AD200, uh...homages, such as the Triopo F1-200 & F1-250, Yongnuo YN-200, Visico 2 (aka the Neewer Vision2), and Neewer Q3. All of them have fixed heads; all of them are in different incompatible radio triggering systems.
The Neewer Q3 units are not made by Godox and are completely incompatible as reported by other folks who purchased them assuming they were the same thing. I suspect they are Meike because the older Neewer QC transmitter (before the Neewer QPro came out as an Godox XPro lookalike) has a similar case to the Meike GT620, but as they're not identical in UI, that's not proof.
Generic Rebranding
However, a lot of Chinese flash gear does get extensively rebranded, and Neewer used to rebrand Godox's 2.4 GHz "X" system gear (e.g., the Neewer NW880 was the Godox TT685; the Neewer NW860 II was the Godox V860 II); but they don't appear to have any Godox gear, aside from the older non-compatible models (e.g., the Godox TT560 which has no radio in it is the Neewer TT560; and also used to be the Amazon Basics Flash) under their brand any more.
And Neewer is particularly problematic since they're a generic rebranding, bringing together a host of different gear under one label, assumably to make it easier to sell. Their flash gear has at various times been identified as models made by Godox, Yongnuo, Meike, Triopo, Visico, etc. So, "Neewer" as a brand does not indicate compatibility with anything else that's branded "Neewer". You have to do more research.
Rebranding for Support
There is also a different kind of rebranding that is done for a different purpose. Adorama rebrands Godox gear as "Flashpoint R2"; Essential Photos in the UK rebrands it as "Pixapro" and Quadralite as "Stroboss" so that they can easily identify who to extend customer and warranty support to. If it's rebranded, it was clearly purchased from them.
With Jinbei's RT system, which is rebranded as Westcott FJ in the US and Rollei Freeze HS in Europe, an older reputable company is adopting a subset of models from their lineup to expand their own offerings. And they take over the customer/warranty support/repair issues under their rebranding as well.
Originally by user27440. Source · Licensed CC BY-SA 4.0
user27440
2y ago
0
Generated from our catalog & community — verify before relying on it.
No. Based on the community answers, Neewer’s Q system is not the same as Godox’s X system, and they are not radio-compatible with each other.
Some Neewer products may look very similar to Godox models, but physical resemblance does not mean they are identical internally or share the same wireless protocol. The answers note that the user interfaces differ, and that the Neewer Q3 is not the same as a Godox AD200 Pro—for example, the Q3 has a fixed head, while the AD200 Pro is known for interchangeable heads.
This kind of “lookalike” design is common with flash gear. Other brands also make products that resemble an AD200-style light, but they often use their own separate triggering systems.
So if you want a setup where all flashes and triggers work together seamlessly, it’s safest to stay within one radio ecosystem: Neewer Q with Neewer Q, or Godox X with Godox X. Don’t assume cross-brand compatibility just because the products look alike.
Recommended products
UniqueBot
AI2y ago
Your Answer
Related Questions
No related questions yet.